Retailer offers

Strong Partnerships Can Drive Sales

by Susan Zweibaum on January 11, 2012

Yesterday, while reading my New York Times I came across an offer that just blew my socks off and made me wonder if it wasn’t almost too extreme.  However, upon further thought I realized that this promotion was perfect for a few reasons that I will get to shortly.

So, what is this amazing offer?  How about a free Nook?  Seriously.  It was a full-page ad offering a free Nook Simple Touch (the basic, not color) with a full-year Nook subscription to the New York Times.   The offer also showed up in an email offer from Barnes & Noble.   And for those wanting the more tablet style product, you could also get $99 off a Nook Color instead.   What made this offer so interesting was the partnership between the New York Times and Barnes & Noble and the way that the New York Times was leveraging their digital assets, something that has been key to their recent success in the marketplace. 

Truthfully, this isn’t anything new.  Think of getting discounted or free phones when you sign up for mobile phone service.  However, this is the first time an e-reader and a digital content provider have linked together to create such an offer.

Let’s take a closer look at the offer and why it makes sense from both the Barnes & Noble and the New York Times standpoints.


This is the key to the whole story, and while I still want to talk about the marketing side, none of that matters if the ROI isn’t there.  A Nook Simple Touch costs $99.  A one-year Nook subscription to the NY Times is $239.88.  It is likely that the cost of the Nook is being funded by the New York Times and likely at a discounted rate, but I don’t know this for a fact.  I can also tell you that People Magazine is doing a similar offer, but their subscription is only $119.88 and I read that People and B&N are sharing the cost.  This makes sense as the ROI wouldn’t be there for People if it hadn’t shared the expense of the e-readers.   No matter how you slice it, this becomes a win-win for both parties, although an expensive initial outlay for the New York Times.  While not knowing the costs associated with the digital subscription, I am venturing that the New York Times is still making money.  Additionally, most people will likely renew their subscription once they have it, leading to a more long-term proposition and repeat sales (the key to any promotion).  From the B&N standpoint, a person who has an e-reader is going to continue to buy books and other subscriptions, which in turn drives their revenue up as well.

 The Buzz

Somewhat surprisingly, B&N beat Amazon to this kind of offer.  The reason I see this as surprising is that Amazon has historically been the innovator in this market and has the greater marketshare.  How likely do you think Amazon will construct a copycat deal?  Fairly likely, especially if they see it working in terms of an increase in Nook sales.  They will do anything to make sure they continue to be the leader.  Nook is behind in overall e-reader sales, but the kind of buzz this offer generates can only help them grow sales and market share.  Combine that with the good reviews the Nook has gotten and you have a winning formula.   Let me state, however, that there are some blog posts and news items taking a slightly cynical approach to the offer.  For instance, they suggest you would only take advantage of this offer if you were already thinking about a New York Times e-reader subscription.  Others have pointed to the fact that B&N has hinted of spinning off the Nook to a separate group citing lower than expected sales.  They all may have a point, but the partnership is the key here and it is a good strategy for both to attempt this kind of promotion.  Brands in second place often need to step out of the box to generate attention and sales when they are competing with such a behemoth as Amazon.

Let’s not forget the buzz this offer is creating for the New York TimesThis offer is another example of how they are utilizing their digital content to reach more customers and in a different way.  What’s more, there are a myriad number of stories on the Net talking about this offer.  It is all positive buzz for B&N and the New York Times.


Good partnerships drive good promotions.  Why do you think companies sponsor events and teams and have endorsement deals?  In this case, the New York Times is looking to grow their digital subscribership and need a partner to deliver it.  You can get the on any computer, but an e-reader is different; you need a subscription.  Giving the consumer the reader if they get a subscription is a great way to drive subscriptions.  Sort of like when razor companies give away the razor handle in order to drive razor blade sales (which is where they make all their money anyway).    

Only time will tell if this is successful and if Amazon will follow suit.  In the meantime, I hope the winning formula proves itself to be a way to drive long-term sales for both B&N and the New York Times.


“Would You Like to Try One?”

by Susan Zweibaum on May 12, 2011

Keys to Developing a Successful Sampling Campaign

Sampling is an important tactic within marketing and there are a variety of sampling types and vehicles you can use to distribute your product to a target audience.  Additionally, there are many times within a product’s lifecycle that you may want to sample, including a new product launch, trial to a new or expanded target audience, as a sales incentive with a retailer, to name just a few.  However, sampling programs are a not one-size-fits-all proposition and each brand team should approach their plan through a customized lens that looks at who is your target, where do you find them, how big is your budget and how are you measuring success?  Sampling also should be approached as an integrated effort and not just a standalone tactic.  It works best when supported by a larger marketing communications plan.

I have developed many sampling programs throughout my career.  They have ranged from the very small (1000 units) to the very large (14 million units) and in each case I examined the key components I am outlining for you below.   I would like to tell you that there is a magic formula for successful sampling, but there really isn’t.  Different sampling vehicles have unique response rates and each target demographic responds differently to each sampling method as well as your individual product.  Sampling won’t help if the product doesn’t connect with your target audience.   If you develop a sampling plan methodically and take into account these considerations you will be more likely to be successful.

1)       Make sure sampling is the right vehicle for your product:  Not every product should be sampled or can be sampled effectively given the size of your budget.  Establish strong objectives and goals for the sampling program and make sure that sampling will help you achieve those goals.  For instance, your product must be refrigerated but you don’t want to sample at retail and you want to reach 250,000 18-24 year olds with a budget of only $150,000. Sampling may not be feasible in this case, and you may want to change your parameters or your goals.

2)      Be Targeted:  Sampling will be totally ineffective if your sample doesn’t hit your target audience effectively and efficiently.  For instance, you don’t want to sample at Spring Break if your target audience is 45 to 54 year-old women.  The more targeted the sampling the higher chance of converting that sample to trial and ultimately to purchase.  That doesn’t mean that all your sampling should be direct mail, but you want to ensure that the greatest number of samples are reaching your target without duplication.

3)      Test-and-Learn:  What seems like a good way to sample may turn out to be the absolute worst, either due to the delivery method, the fulfillment agency or the venue.  On the other hand, what seemed like a slightly odd venue may turn out to be the most productive in terms of trial.  When possible, test smaller programs to determine if they are delivering the ROI you need and they are meeting the objectives of the total program.  Once you’ve determined which programs are going to be successful, build these into your larger plan.  Sampling is often part of the long-term strategy and something that a brand does every year.  In these cases, test-and-learns offer the most effective means of developing a truly efficient and successful sampling plan with programs that work well for the brand.  For others, sampling is just part of a new product launch and seen as a short-term hit.  If that is the case, then test-and-learns are tougher, but still can be considered as part of the in-market test phase of the product launch.

4)      Include as part of an integrated plan:  Sampling in and of itself will not necessarily drive sales.  Sampling should be part of a broader plan that drives awareness and trial.  Just because a person has tried a product and liked it doesn’t mean that they will automatically go and buy it.  In-store offers, online advertising and outreach, advertising and other media vehicles will continue to drive awareness and remind that consumer of the product they sampled.  In some cases, they will receive the sample but not try it until they are reminded by the other messages around them.  Include different sample delivery methods that coordinate with your integrated plan to broaden your reach and provide an ability to determine the best vehicle that drives trial and purchase by your target audience.

5)      Look for Value-Added Programs:  Often sampling is part of a larger sponsorship or media partnership.  These sampling opportunities may be tougher to see a positive ROI, but they often bring a more intrinsic connection to your brand’s psychographic as well as increased opportunities for expanded media.

6)      Provide a sales incentive to trial:  Even when someone has tried a sample and liked it, they often need some help putting it in their kitchen cabinet.  A financial incentive such as a coupon will bridge any hesitation the consumer has in a first-time purchase.  Furthermore, if you are conducting a sampling program as part of a customer marketing initiative or a retailer direct mail program, the retailer is more likely to support the program if there is an incentive sending that consumer into the store to purchase.

7)      Research and Measurement:  Use market research for as many sampling programs as possible in order to determine actual ROI.  Use outside, third-party test methods and do not rely on the sampling agency results or standardized questions.  You want to develop research questions that are appropriate to your brand and brand objectives.  You want to achieve a positive ROI based on purchase intent and actual incremental purchase, and the only way to determine that is through research.  When used in conjunction with test-and-learn scenarios, you will begin to develop a sampling plan that will drive incremental sales.  Additionally, use a consistent measurement methodology across each program so that you ensure an apples-to-apples comparison.

8)      Evaluate and Adjust:  Go back at the end of the year and evaluate all of your sampling vehicles both separately and as a whole.  Determine your overall program ROI and evaluate if each vehicle and the total plan is delivering against objectives.  If your sampling initiatives occur year over year, adjust your plan based on the evaluations of objectives and ROI.

So, how you may ask does this translate to the real world?  Here is an example.

A brand team was given the challenge of delivering 8 million samples for a product launch, but they were told to keep the delivery cost to an average of $.12.  The only way the agency putting the plan together could deliver that was to utilize commodity sampling, meaning that they throw them out there broadly the cheapest way possible with limited ability to ensure the target was getting the product with no duplication.  The actual ROI was around $.20 when what they wanted was much closer to $1.00.  There was limited market research so they had no way of determining if the sampling worked.  One year post launch they were still sampling this way and there was little additional promotional activity to connect the sample to the overall brand message.  A lot of money spent with little to show for it.

As year two and three plans were executed the sampling plan evolved and the team moved away from commodity sampling to a more integrated approach.  They looked for vehicles that provided added value through additional media, sponsorships and coupons.  They moved to more targeted vehicles such as direct mail and retailer sponsored programs that while more expensive deliver the product directly into the hands of the target and offer more of an incentive to purchase.  They added market research to every program and began to eliminate vehicles which were not working for them.  By the end of the third year the overall ROI was around $1.00 and they upped the number of samples to 14 million.

I have determined through working with many different products that developing a successful  integrated sampling plan is a little bit art and a little bit science.  You need to fully understand your target audience and their motivations – demographics and psychographics, but you also need to look at the program financials, ROI and market research results.  You also need to do your research.  There are so many different ways to get a product into the hands of your target consumer and you need to search a little to find ones that will fulfill your product goals.  I discover new vehicles every day that can get a product out there in ways I never have thought of.  Just do some web surfing and listen to the vendors that call.

In a future post I will provide some examples of good sampling programs that have taken these concepts into account.


A New Definition for Mobile Marketing

March 2, 2011

Years ago when I first started working in marketing and promotions mobile marketing meant literally a mobile event, often a truck or promotional vehicle.  I worked on many of these traveling exhibits that delivered an interactive experience for the consumer.  We handed out samples, supported PR events and delivered unique and interesting experiences for the […]

Read the full article →

Social Media and Your Neighborhood Cheese Shop

February 23, 2011

Recently, I have started “friending” some of my favorite local stores that I go to repeatedly.  I had been slow to the practice wondering what the point was (I am not one of those early adopters), but have discovered that I like seeing the updates of the “special of the week” or announcement of a […]

Read the full article →